Sign up to receive an email update when a new issue of Sound Waves is available.

close window

Link to USGS home page
Sound Waves Monthly Newsletter - Coastal Science and Research News from Across the USGS
Home || Sections: Cover Stories | Fieldwork | Research | Outreach | Meetings | Awards | Staff & Center News | Publications || Archives

 

Publications

Structured Decision Making in Barrier Island Restoration: Study Demonstrates the Potential for Informing Management Decisions and Guiding the Focus of Scientific Research



in this issue:
 previous story | next story

A new study, “Use of structured decision-making to explicitly incorporate environmental process understanding in management of coastal restoration projects: Case study on barrier islands of the northern Gulf of Mexico,” demonstrates the use of a decision-analysis tool to inform management of coastal restoration projects and identify high-priority research gaps.

The focus of the study is the planned restoration of Ship Island, Mississippi, a once-contiguous barrier island in the northern Gulf of Mexico that has been split in two since Hurricane Camille (1967). As part of the Mississippi Coastal Improvements Program, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers plans to use approximately 22 million cubic yards of sand to close the gap between East and West Ship Islands and nourish the eastern end to enhance the supply of sand via longshore transport.

Map showing the location of Ship Island, Mississippi.
Above: Map showing the location of Ship Island, Mississippi. The focus of the study is the planned restoration of Ship Island, Mississippi, a once-contiguous barrier island in the northern Gulf of Mexico that has been split in two since Hurricane Camille (1967). [larger version]

The project will take place in five phases over approximately three years. If a tropical storm occurs during construction and damages the project, management decisions will have to be made regarding if and when (i.e., which construction phase) repairs should be made to maximize the likelihood that the project will achieve its objectives of habitat restoration and protecting the mainland from waves. 

In this study, structured decision-making (SDM) was evaluated as a tool for incorporating data and environmental process knowledge directly into coastal restoration management decisions. The transparent SDM process included soliciting input from stakeholders on project objectives and relative importance, and from scientists and engineers on the physical drivers and response of the system. This input was incorporated into a probabilistic framework that linked storm inundation data, the physical response of the island, repair decisions, and sand and budget constraints to the quantitative impacts on project objectives. If the project incurs damage during construction, this framework will be used to inform decisions made in response. For example, the analysis indicated that it is more cost effective to repair major damage immediately despite the additional cost of moving equipment, rather than wait until a subsequent construction phase and risk additional damage to the weakened project.

Example of a simplified influence diagram developed in building a structured decision-making framework at Ship Island, in this case representing a single decision on whether or not to repair a major breach in Phase B2.
Above: Example of a simplified influence diagram developed in building a structured decision-making framework at Ship Island, in this case representing a single decision on whether or not to repair a major breach in Phase B2. Influence diagrams conceptually link system drivers and response, budget and sand constraints, management decisions, and the objectives of the project. A Bayesian (probabilistic) network was developed to statistically evaluate the quantitative impact of possible damage and response decisions on project objectives. [larger version]

In addition to providing a framework for analyzing decisions at Ship Island, this effort identified several key gaps in scientific understanding of barrier island dynamics that limit the ability to robustly manage coastal restoration projects. For example, there is relatively high uncertainty in predicting the relation between island width and storm resilience, and in quantifying the potential benefits of upstream sand nourishment on project longevity.  

This study demonstrates the potential for structured decision-making to directly incorporate scientific and engineering knowledge into a framework that can both improve coastal restoration management and identify priority gaps in data, predicting model capability, and process understanding that can be filled with targeted scientific research.

This effort included collaborators from the USGS, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Institute of Silviculture, Applied Coastal Research and Engineering, the National Park Service, and the Louisiana Coastal Protection and Restoration Authority. Funding was provided by the Department of the Interior Southeast Climate Science Center.

The full citation for the article is:

Dalyander, P.S., Meyers, M., Mattsson, B.J., Steyer, G., Godsey, E., McDonald, J., Byrnes, M., and Ford, M., 2016, Use of structured decision-making to explicitly incorporate environment process understanding in management of coastal restoration projects:  Case study on barrier islands of the northern Gulf of Mexico:  Journal of Environmental Management, doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2016.08.078.

Related Sound Waves Stories
Meeting to Coordinate USGS Data Management to Support Ocean Planning
July / Aug. 2013
Storm Impact, Sea-Floor Change, and Barrier-Island Evolution
March 2009

Related Websites
Use of structured decision-making to explicitly incorporate environment process understanding in management of coastal restoration projects
Journal of Environmental Management
Using a Bayesian network to predict barrier island geomorphologic characteristics
Journal of Geophysical Research

 previous story | next story

 

print this issue print this issue

in this issue:

Cover Story
SE Beach Dunes Lost to Hurricane Matthew

News Briefs
News Briefs

Fieldwork
Indian Ocean Gas Hydrates Drilling

Recent Fieldwork

Research
Measuring Coastal Erosion in California

Solid Footing for Offshore Wind Turbines

Outreach
Woods Hole Science Stroll

Awards
James Hein Wins Moore Medal Award

International Recognition for Historic Elwha River Restoration

Meetings
AGU Fall Meeting

International Symposium on Deep-Sea Corals

SACNAS National Conference

Staff
Visiting Scholar Studying Arctic Ocean Ferromanganese Crusts and Nodules

Publications
Structured Decision Making in Barrier Island Restoration

Oct. - Dec. Publications

Accessibility FOIA Privacy Policies and Notices

Take Pride in America logo USA.gov logo U.S. Department of the Interior | U.S. Geological Survey
URL: http://soundwaves.usgs.gov/2016/12/pubs.html
Page Contact Information: Feedback
Page Last Modified: January 03, 2017 @ 12:15 PM